Appealing a decision of the Independent Football Regulator: A practical guide to navigating the appeals process

The Independent Football Regulator (IFR) is open for business. It will soon start to grant and revoke operating licences, decide whether an owner is fit to run a club, impose financial conditions, and in the most serious cases remove individuals from their positions or bar a club from competition. After years of self-regulation, English football now has a regulator with real teeth. But for clubs, owners, officers and anyone else in the IFR’s sights, one key question to start thinking about is: what happens if you need to appeal?

Part 9 of the Football Governance Act 2025 has the answer: a two-stage process that includes an internal review inside the IFR itself and, in some situations, an appeal before the Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT). Both routes come with tight deadlines and important tactical choices. This article seeks to provide a comprehensive guide to how it all works in practice and, more importantly, what you should be doing before you receive an IFR decision that you might want to challenge.

FIRST THINGS FIRST: CAN YOU CHALLENGE THE IFR DECISION?

Before anything else, you need to check Schedule 10 of the Act, which lists the 27 categories of “reviewable decisions” that can be challenged, including licensing refusals and conditions, decisions regarding clubs relocating or changing their home ground, directions relating to unsuitable owners and officers, disqualification orders, financial penalties, and others. For decisions that are on the list, the process can be broadly summarised as follows:

  • If you are a “directly affected” party, you can ask the IFR to look at its decision again through an internal review. If the internal review does not resolve matters, the directly affected party can then appeal to the CAT, which applies either a full merits review or judicial review principles depending on the nature of the challenge.

  • For six categories of the most serious, high-stakes decisions, there is an additional option available to anyone with a “sufficient interest”: skipping the internal review and going straight to the CAT for a full merits hearing.

THE INTERNAL REVIEW

Who can ask for a review?

Only a “concerned person”, which is someone the IFR considers to be “directly affected” by the decision, can request an internal review. In practice, this will almost always be the club, owner or officer who is the subject of the decision – i.e. the club whose licence is being refused or conditioned, the prospective owner whose suitability has been determined, or the officer facing a disqualification order. Notably, this “directly affected” threshold is far narrower than the bar for a CAT appeal, which we come back to below.

Consider, for example, a supporters’ trust seeking to challenge a controversial ownership determination. The trust will almost certainly be unable to trigger an internal review, as it is unlikely to be “directly affected” in the required sense, but it may well have a “sufficient interest” to bring a CAT appeal. That gap between the two standing thresholds is not academic - it determines who gets a voice in the process, and when.

The IFR can also consolidate internal reviews, whether because several concerned persons challenge the same decision, or because separate decisions raise common issues. For co-owners or multiple officers facing related findings, this means your challenge may end up being run alongside - or merged with - someone else’s.

The time limits are tight, so plan ahead

The most immediate thing to note about the internal review process is how fast you need to move once you have been notified of the IFR’s decision:

  • Stage 1, Initial Request (7 days): Within 7 days of being notified of the decision you must file an Initial Request document, no more than a single side of A4, identifying the decision, explaining why you are a “concerned person”, summarising at a high-level what you think the errors are, and stating what outcome you want. The IFR is not expecting full legal submissions at this stage, but it does need to be substantive enough to get the review off the ground.

  • Stage 2, Complete Request (14 days): Your full submissions and evidence, capped at 25 pages (excluding new evidence), is due within 14 days of notification (i.e. just seven days after the Initial Request). Extensions beyond the 14-day deadline are available only in what the Framework calls “the most exceptional circumstances”.

Submitting a Complete Request within 14 days is very tight. If you are waiting for the decision to arrive before you start thinking about your grounds of challenge, you are probably already too late. The parties who will use this process most effectively are the ones who have already, before any decision lands, identified the likely issues, thought through what evidence they may need for an appeal, and drafted at least a skeleton of what they might argue. In particular, for clubs involved in contested ownership bids, licensing reviews, or anything else where a difficult decision may be on the horizon, it will be important to get ahead.

Who actually looks at your review?

Not every review is conducted by the same body. Schedule 10 assigns each of the 27 reviewable decisions to one of two review bodies:

  • An Expert Panel Committee handles 18 of the 27 categories; the day-to-day regulatory decisions, including licensing conditions, approval decisions, directions about unsuitable owners and officers, urgent directions, and financial penalties. The Expert Panel is designed to bring in legal, financial, and industry expertise from outside the IFR’s own structure.

  • The IFR Board reviews the remaining nine decisions; the most consequential ones including provisional licence revocations, suitability determinations for owners and officers, disqualification orders, prohibited competitions, ownership removal orders, distribution orders, and licence suspension or revocation. There is an obvious tension here: the Board reviewing its own institution’s most serious decisions is not a structure that screams independence. That is not a criticism unique to the IFR - it is a common feature of first-stage regulatory review - but it is one of the reasons why CAT oversight of these decisions matters so much.

What standard does the reviewer apply?

The Act does not specify a fixed standard of review. Instead, the test is whether the IFR’s decision was “materially wrong”, and what that means in practice will depend on the nature of the decision being reviewed. The guidance draws a distinction: a decision turning on matters of regulatory strategy and judgement that Parliament has entrusted to the IFR “may be afforded a greater margin of discretion”, so we anticipate the reviewer will likely defer to the IFR’s original decision rather than substitute its own assessment; whereas a decision turning on “binary disputes of fact” – e.g. did the club meet a specific financial threshold, did the prospective owner’s submission contain the required information - is “likely to be afforded a more limited margin of discretion”, giving the reviewer a stronger basis to look closely at whether the IFR actually got it right, rather than simply asking whether its conclusion was within the bounds of reason.

A club challenging the IFR’s assessment of whether its proposed stadium relocation meets the fanbase impact criteria illustrates this distinction well. If the IFR has applied a specific threshold (e.g. whether a certain proportion of fans would face materially longer journey times) and the club argues that the wrong data set was used or the wrong postcodes were mapped, that is a relatively binary factual question, giving the reviewer some discretion to look closely at whether the IFR got it right.

The absence of a fixed standard gives the system flexibility while it finds its feet. But it also means the early published review decisions will be very closely watched. They will be the first real indication of how hard the reviewer is prepared to push back on the IFR’s reasoning, and that will matter a great deal for how parties approach the process going forward.

In terms of timing, the reviewer has 28 days to reach a decision, with a possible 14-day extension for “special reasons”. If the IFR misses that window, the original decision is automatically treated as upheld, and that deemed outcome can be appealed to the CAT. Otherwise, the reviewer can uphold, vary, or cancel the original decision, and its reasoning must be published.

What happens at an oral hearing?

Where the reviewer decides an oral hearing is needed, it will ordinarily take place within 14 days of the review panel being constituted. Importantly, this is not designed to feel like a CAT hearing or a court trial: the framework is explicit that oral hearings are not adversarial, are not an opportunity for the IFR to plead its case, and do not involve cross-examination of witnesses. They exist so the panel can ask questions and seek clarification on the written submissions already before it. A practical consequence worth noting: individuals with direct knowledge of the underlying facts - for example, the owner whose suitability is in question – are expected to attend and be available to answer the panel’s questions.

Asking for a review does not put the decision on hold

This is one of the most important practical points of note - triggering the internal review process does not automatically suspend the decision you are challenging. There is no automatic pause. Whilst for most decisions the reviewer has discretion to put the decision on hold while it considers the matter, for a specific category of decisions (those designed to take immediate effect, to protect the game’s integrity, or to stop ongoing harm), even that discretion is gone. So, if your club has had its licence suspended, that suspension is live from the moment the original decision is made, regardless of whether you file an internal review appeal.

Consider a club that receives a licence suspension three days before a transfer window closes. The suspension takes effect from the moment the decision is made. Filing an internal review request does not pause it. The club cannot register new players, and its sponsor relationships will be under immediate strain. Every day of delay has a tangible cost. This scenario illustrates why the response and legal challenge must move forward at speed. It also raises the question of whether a party in that position could go to the High Court and seek an emergency injunction (we come back to this below in the context of CAT appeals).

Costs: don’t ignore them

If the internal review goes against you, the IFR can seek to recover its costs. The reviewer will weigh up the merits of your challenge, how you conducted yourself during the process, the reasonableness of what the IFR spent, and your financial resources. The IFR’s own internal legal costs cannot be recovered; only panel fees, external counsel and advisers, and reasonable case-specific costs. For large clubs or well-resourced owners, this may not be a significant concern. However, for smaller clubs and individuals facing disqualification, the prospect of a costs order landing on top of an unsuccessful review might be a genuine deterrent.

Confidentiality: be specific or lose the argument

Review decisions are published, but there is a short window before publication in which you can ask for certain information to be treated as confidential. That said, the framework is clear that vague or sweeping confidentiality claims will not be accepted. Given that IFR proceedings involving prominent clubs or high-profile ownership matters are likely to attract press attention, the question of what is, and is not, going to end up in the public domain is one to address right at the start of any challenge, not as an afterthought.

GOING TO THE COMPETITION APPEAL TRIBUNAL

What can you appeal?

Two categories of decision can be taken to the CAT. First, the six ‘high-stakes‘ decisions: namely operating licence revocations and suspensions, owner and officer suitability determinations, and disqualification orders. Anyone facing one of these decisions can go straight to the CAT without going through an internal review first. The catch, however, is that you cannot run both routes simultaneously; if you start an internal review, you cannot appeal to the CAT until that review is finished. You have to pick a lane and stick with it.

Second, review decisions: whatever outcome the internal review produces - whether it upholds, varies, or overturns the original decision - can be appealed to the CAT. This includes “deemed” review decisions, where the IFR refuses to conduct a review, or fails to notify you of the review outcome within the prescribed 28-day window. The system is designed so there is always a path to the CAT, even when the internal review process has not produced the result you’re after.

Who can bring a CAT appeal?

The CAT’s door is open wider than the internal review’s: anyone with a “sufficient interest” can bring an appeal in the CAT. This is the same broad threshold that applies in judicial review. In any other sector, that might be an unremarkable point. In football, however, it is not. English football generates more passionately engaged stakeholders per decision than almost any other regulated industry. A ruling that a prospective owner is unsuitable, or a distribution order that redirects hundreds of millions of pounds down the football pyramid, will be watched intensely by fans, community groups, supporters trusts, local councils, creditors, rival clubs, and others. Some of them will have strong arguments that their interest is sufficient to get them through the CAT’s door, others probably won’t.

There is, however, a practical sting in the tail for such third-party stakeholders. As above, for the non-high-stakes decisions, internal review is mandatory before any CAT appeal, and only a party that is “directly affected” can request that review. A fan group is unlikely to be “directly affected” in the relevant sense, which means it cannot trigger the internal review itself. So, unless the directly affected party has already gone through the internal review process, the fan group’s path to the CAT is likely blocked for this category of decisions, however strong its “sufficient interest” argument might be.

Expect the early years of IFR litigation to include genuine battles about who gets to appeal in the first place. A broad approach to standing risks turning the CAT into an arena for every grievance in English football, whereas a narrow approach risks shutting out parties with a real and legitimate stake in the outcome. Where exactly the tribunal draws that line will be a defining feature of the new regime.

21 days to appeal, and the clock starts immediately

An appeal to the CAT must be filed within 21 days of notification of the decision. And in this case, the notice of appeal is not a placeholder - it has to set out the substance of your case, including the key facts and legal arguments. You cannot file a short-form notice and develop the grounds later. For parties who have already been through the internal review, at least some of that work will have been done. But for parties going directly to the CAT against a high-stakes decision, 21 days to draft and file a substantive appeal against a major regulatory decision is extremely tight.

A distribution order, which could redirect hundreds of millions of pounds in broadcasting revenues from the top of the pyramid to lower leagues, illustrates the point starkly. A League Two club that considers itself materially short-changed by such an order, or a Premier League club that believes the redistribution formula has been applied incorrectly, has 21 days from notification to file a notice of appeal that sets out its legal arguments, the factual basis of its case, and the relief it is seeking. That is not a long time for a business that may have no prior experience of CAT litigation.

The standard of review at the CAT: two completely different standards

The single most important thing to understand about CAT appeals is that the standard of review is not the same for all decisions, and the difference is significant.

For the six high-stakes decisions, the CAT will conduct a full merits review. This means that it will not simply check whether the IFR made a legal error; instead, it looks at the whole thing again from scratch. Fresh evidence is admissible. Witnesses can be cross-examined. The CAT can substitute its own decision. This gives appellants a genuinely meaningful second chance. The CAT’s decisions on these high-stakes merits appeals will, over time, effectively write the substantive law of IFR regulation.

For all other decisions, however, the CAT will apply judicial review principles, namely legality, rationality, procedural fairness. Here, it is not asking whether it would have decided differently; it is asking whether the IFR made a legal or procedural error serious enough to require the decision to be set aside. That is a much harder bar to clear. But it is not an easy ride for the IFR either. The CAT is a specialist tribunal with genuine depth and expertise in financial and economic regulation. In our experience, it will not be satisfied by vague assurances that the IFR ‘took all relevant factors into account’. Where the IFR’s reasoning is thin, inconsistent, or procedurally irregular, we anticipate that the CAT’s specialist composition will be an asset for the appellant.

Appealing to the CAT does not pause the decision

The same no-automatic-stay rule that applies at the internal review stage applies at the CAT too. Lodging a notice of appeal does not suspend the decision you are challenging. And for the same categories of decision that cannot be stayed at the internal review stage (urgent directions, owner and officer directions, prohibited competition designations, and the most serious licensing sanctions), the Act expressly says the CAT has no power to grant a stay at all.

That statutory exclusion of the CAT’s power raises a question which we expect to be litigated sooner rather than later: can a party go to the High Court instead and seek an emergency injunction using that court’s own inherent jurisdiction? The argument would be that Parliament removed the CAT’s power to grant a stay, but said nothing expressly about the High Court’s powers. Whether that works will turn on how the courts read the exclusivity of the Part 9 framework: was the intention to remove interim relief entirely, or just to keep it away from the CAT specifically? It is a live question, and one that practitioners should have in mind for the most urgent and high-value cases.

Open justice in the CAT

Most disputes in English football are resolved through behind closed doors arbitrations, which are private, confidential, and entirely shielded from public view. The CAT is a fundamentally different environment. The CAT is committed to open justice: hearings are livestreamed, notices of appeal are publicly accessible, and the full factual story of a challenge - including uncomfortable details about an owner’s conduct or a club’s internal governance - will be out in the open in real time. For high-profile clubs or owners, the reputational consequences can be as significant as the regulatory ones, so that will need to be part of the overall calculation when deciding whether and how to appeal.

THE BIG DECISION: DO YOU TAKE THE INTERNAL REVIEW ROUTE, OR GO STRAIGHT TO THE CAT?

For anyone facing one of the six ‘high-stakes’ decisions, this is one of the most important strategic questions in the whole process, and there is no default right answer. There are considerations on both sides:

  • The case for going through IFR internal review first. The internal review process is designed to be the quicker route to an outcome: it runs on a short, fixed statutory clock, with a lighter-touch procedure than CAT litigation, so it offers the best chance of resolving matters quickly without the cost and public scrutiny of CAT litigation. And even if it does not, it forces the IFR to set out its reasoning in detail, which tells you exactly what you are up against before you go to the CAT. It can also buy time to prepare for a CAT appeal, which in some situations might have genuine value.

  • The case for going straight to the CAT. The quicker-route advantage of internal review only materialises if the review actually resolves matters in your favour. If it does not, you have not saved time at all: the 28-day review period is simply added on top of the CAT timetable, and for decisions that bite immediately, that delay could be damaging. There is also a structural issue with internal review: for the high-stakes decisions in particular, it is the IFR Board reviewing its own institution’s most consequential calls, and if that review upholds the original decision, you are left with a published document reinforcing the original conclusion sitting in the public record before you even get to the CAT. Going straight to the CAT also avoids running up costs and management time on two sequential processes, when the CAT’s full merits review was always going to be the real forum for a serious dispute. And because the CAT looks at the question afresh, with new evidence and cross-examination available, nothing of substance is lost by skipping a review stage whose outcome will not bind or limit what can be argued at the second-stage tribunal in any event.

There is also a tactical dimension to the timing question. A party that is minded to go to the CAT but thinks 21 days is not enough time to prepare its best case could potentially use the internal review as a staging post: the review period effectively extends the runway before CAT proceedings begin. If the IFR takes the full 28 days (plus a possible 14-day extension) to issue its review decision, the party has been given additional time to marshal its evidence, refine its legal arguments, and instruct its CAT team properly; time it would not have had if it went straight to the tribunal. Advisers should be alive to this possibility and factor it into the route-choice analysis.

For decisions that are not high-stakes, this choice does not arise - internal review is mandatory before any CAT appeal is possible. That makes the quality of the internal review submission critical. In these cases, the CAT will not re-examine the substance of the decision; it will only ask whether the IFR acted lawfully, rationally, and fairly. That means a weak or poorly prepared internal review submission cannot be rescued on appeal, as the CAT will not hear the substantive arguments from scratch. It is therefore crucial that you treat the internal review as your primary opportunity to make your best case, not as a box to tick before the ‘real’ proceedings begin in the CAT.

WHAT TO DO IN ADVANCE OF RECEIVING A DECISION

Where a challenging IFR decision is on the horizon, there are practical steps that clubs, owners, officers, and their advisers should be taking now:

  • Check Schedule 10 now. Know in advance whether the decisions you are most exposed to are reviewable, and which reviewer would be responsible. That mapping is the foundation of any challenge strategy.

  • Start building your challenge before the decision arrives. 14 days to prepare a Complete Request (for an internal review), or 21 days to prepare a notice of appeal (in the CAT), will go by quickly. If you are involved in an ownership process, a licence assessment, or anything else where a difficult decision is foreseeable, you should already be thinking about what your grounds of challenge would be and what evidence you might need. For ownership processes in particular, financial and due-diligence records should be organised and accessible before the IFR’s decision lands.

  • Decide which route you would take. For the six high-stakes decisions, the route-choice question (internal review versus straight to the CAT) is one of the most consequential strategic decisions you will face. The analysis should be done in advance. Consider whether there is value in the IFR being required to set out its reasoning in detail before you go to the CAT? Do you have 21 days’ worth of CAT-ready material, or would the internal review period give you useful additional time to prepare?

  • Think about potential co-appellants. The CAT’s “sufficient interest” standing threshold is deliberately broad. A distribution order or an ownership determination will attract interest from a wider group of stakeholders, including fan groups, rival clubs, supporters’ trusts, creditors, and others. Some of them might have a viable path to the CAT. Planning only for your own challenge, without considering who else might be involved, risks being caught off-guard when third parties file appeals of their own, potentially on different grounds and with different evidence.

  • Work out the suspensive effect position. Identify whether the relevant decision is in a category that cannot be stayed, and build your operational and legal strategy around that answer. If a stay is available through the Part 9 process, consider preparing the interim relief application in advance so that it can be filed immediately on the decision being handed down. If a stay is not available through the Part 9 process, think about whether the High Court might be worth exploring.

  • Get ahead of confidentiality early. Vague or blanket claims for confidentiality will not be accepted. In a high-profile regime where decisions are published and CAT hearings are livestreamed, identifying what is genuinely commercially sensitive, and making a specific, substantiated case for protecting it, needs to be part of your strategy from the outset.

  • Engage specialist counsel early. The CAT is a specialist tribunal with deep expertise in regulatory and economic law. IFR appeals will require advisers who understand both the football governance framework and the CAT’s procedural rules. The 14 and 21-day filing windows mean there is little time to instruct and brief a new team from scratch once a decision arrives. Relationships with suitable counsel should therefore be established in advance.

CONCLUSION

The IFR’s review and appeal architecture is well-constructed - it gives affected parties meaningful access to a specialist tribunal, applies a properly intensive standard of review to the most serious decisions, and builds in procedural protections that should stop the IFR from acting arbitrarily. But it is also demanding. The time limits are extremely tight. The distinction between the full merits review and the judicial review standard creates strategic pressure. And the no-automatic-stay default means that, in the most urgent cases, the challenge process and the operational response to the decision need to happen simultaneously.

There are also several open questions. Can the High Court grant interim relief where the CAT’s power to stay is expressly excluded? How will the CAT approach standing for third-party stakeholders? How will the “materially wrong” standard develop as the first review decisions are published? These questions will shape how the new regulatory regime operates in practice for everyone it touches.

Previous
Previous

Wellness’s Next Growth Story: Investing in Belonging

Next
Next

What Makes an Athlete Marketable in 2026? The Rise of the Athlete Creator